It is time to stop the victim blaming!

It is time to stop the victim blaming!

Today we heard the sentencing of Gary McCourt, the driver who killed Audrey Fyfe in August 2011, and it has generated much anger. At the end of the trial it was announced that Audrey Fyfe was not the first person that he had killed. McCourt had previously been found guilty in 1986 of causing another cyclist’s death by reckless driving. After that offence he was jailed for two years, this time round he has been ordered to carry out 300 hours of community service and given a five year driving ban. There have already been a number of complaints that the sentence was unduly lenient, and that, at the very least, he should have been banned from driving for the rest of his life.

If this wasn’t enough, the Sheriff, James Scott, said that the collision between McCourt and Mrs Fyfe was caused because of a “momentary” loss of concentration. Then he went on to suggest that Mrs Fyfe contributed to her death by not wearing a “safety helmet”, so blaming the victim for her own demise. This sort of victim blaming should be totally unacceptable. Had Mrs Fyfe been walking across the road when she had been hit, there would have been no suggestion that she should have been wearing a pedestrian helmet. What if she had been pushing a pram and he had “clipped” that? Would it still be the victim’s fault? Just because she was cycling, why should she have been expected to wear a plastic hat to protect her? It is not as if it would have provided any protection or prevented her from being hit in the first place. Her death was solely due to McCourt’s actions and the jury convicted him of causing death by careless driving. Mr Scott’s comments are disgraceful and totally unacceptable. I am not the only one to feel this way:

One can only hope that there will be better training of Sheriffs in the future, there is a need to teach them why wearing cycle helmets isn’t compulsory. Lets face it, until the judiciary take safety on the roads seriously, the law will not offer protection to vulnerable road users. For this reason I urge you all to join the Pedal on Parliament protest ride on the 19th May, to call for safer roads for all!

3 thoughts on “It is time to stop the victim blaming!

  1. The Sheriff’s reported comments were ill-informed and unjustifiable. Apparently he has a track-record of highly questionable sentences regarding motorists and cyclists.

    ‘Sheriff Scott had previously sparked anger after sentencing Lady Suzanne Risk to a £200 fine and six points on her licence after she sent Robert Benn, 40, flying off his bike after she failed to see him at a junction in Inverleith Place in October 2009.’

    I believe it’s high time that he should be removed from his post.

    Motorists need to be made to appreciate that their decisions can make the difference between life and death and that driving is a privilege and not a right.

    If cyclists were prone to explode when hit with lethal results for motorists, I envisage that motorists would all exercise extreme care when driving around cyclists.

    The fact is that currently, motorists can call ‘SMIDSY’ or ‘momentary lapse’ and that makes everything OK. Such outrages have to stop.

  2. Would the sheriff make the same comment had she suffered head injuries as a passenger in a car without passenger airbags?

    It sickens me to my toes how drivers like McCourt have the judiciary bending over backwards to explain away their recklessness with the flimsiest excuses, and then suggest that the completely innocent pensioner he mowed down was somehow at fault.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!
%d bloggers like this: